Cuttings - Session 1

This report kicks off a new campaign of Smolthulhu, a rules-lite Call of Cthulhu clone of my own design set in Chicago in 1925. Our investigators:
- Hypatia Magnani, an antiquarian and friend of Laurence Pike
- Zilla Marilla, an occultist who is fairly sure she’s psychic
- Edgar Burrows, a journalist easing into fiction, which is to say, lying professionally
- Melba Vern, a vaudeville performer hoping to rub shoulders with the rich and famous
It started the way these things do: a friend with a problem and no police. Dr. Laurence Pike, administrator of the Oriental Institute at University of Chicago, asked Hypatia to look into a break-in from two nights back. Someone had lifted notes from the office of Dr. Emma Whitlow, concerning an artifact lately hauled out of Syria. Pike wanted no cops. The paperwork on the dig was a little irregular. Probably nothing, but why invite questions.
Pike walked the party down into the basement of the Haskell Museum, past the night watchman, Mr. Lund. Whitlow was cold to them until Pike vouched. Then she laid it out. The thief had taken a metal clipboard case of notes and two books, all tied to her translation of an inscription on an ancient Mesopotamian vase. The vase itself was locked in storage, untouched. It had been found in a cistern, wrapped whole in unglazed ceramic, which kept it in remarkable shape. The sheath had chipped in transit, exposing a strange inscription and a small image of thorned briar.
Whitlow didn’t like the thing. She had read that a similar vase drove an epigrapher named Alistair Hargreave into a panic, and then into an institution. She had been working from his book Fragments of the Thorn Cults. Based on his description, she believed this vase showed a seated figure bound in thorned vines. After many long nights working with the base, she admitted to feeling unnerved and, frankly, superstitious.
Zilla leaned on her until she shared the translation so far:
- [turn?] the face [toward / from??] the one who sits in the thorn.
- Shut the door of the ear and the door of the eye, though the road stands open.
- [stop up] the mouth [of the vessel? of the speaker??] with clay.
The investigators asked who else knew about the vase. Almost no one: the dig team, Pike, Lund, and a Field Museum botanist she’d been consulting, Dr. Julian Hales. Hales had phoned her three nights before the break-in, frantic, demanding to see the vase. She told him to call back in the morning. He never did. She hadn’t been able to reach him since.
Pike fetched an expedition overview. The dig was at Tell Safra, on the middle Khabur river plains. The team: Dr. Walter Ashby (now retired in Hyde Park), Gideon Strand, Frederick Laidlaw, Rupert Selwyn, Dr. Ada Brenner, and the foreman, Rais Yusuf al-Hamdan. Funding came partly from Cordelia Ames of New York, who insisted on Strand as photographer and demanded copies of every plate he made.
Melba inspected the window the intruder used - a neat rectangle cut in the glass, big enough for a child or a very small adult. The bars behind it had been filed down, noisily, then chiseled out of the concrete.
Edgar batted his eyelashes and charmed Whitlow into showing them the vase. Lund unlocked a back room of crates, tools, and tarp-draped statuary, and Whitlow opened a cage at the rear. The vase sat on a workstation in its ceramic sheath, fifteen inches tall. Hypatia studied the exposed patch and had the unpleasant impression that the vines were crawling out of sight. Based on her experience as an antiquarian, she judged that the piece matched the dig site’s region and proposed period. It hadn’t been carried in from afar and buried. It had been made there.
Melba tried to read the room and met Lund’s eyes instead: big, milky, looming over her. She and Zilla pressed him on how a man in the building heard no sawing. He answered slowly, with a great many umms, and dodged most of what he was asked. Pike stepped in. They could ask all the questions they liked, but if they wanted to interrogate his staff, they’d need hard proof.
Melba borrowed a flashlight and went around outside. She found the imprint of a heavy toolbox in the dirt and a cap tucked in the bushes. Stitched in the band: Kessler & Sons, Halsted. Meanwhile Edgar asked for any photos from the dig, which Pike promised to gather, and the investigators got a library card to hunt down copies of the stolen books.
It was seven by the time they left. They decided to split the evening: visit the retired archaeologist and dig leader first, the library later. Dr. Ashby was an old friend of Edgar’s father after all.
His two-story bungalow had a lake view and the feel of a house no one had ever planned to live in. He pretended not to be home. Even after Edgar introduced himself, Ashby greeted them with a revolver. His first question was whether “that bastard, Gideon” was with them.
Once inside, he gave the expedition a bad review: poorly scouted, a mess from the start, and worse after Laidlaw’s breakdown. Laidlaw, the expedition's draftsman, had smashed three of four vases they’d found, a decorative lintel, and a delicate mosaic before they got him restrained.
Gideon, according to Ashby, was neither concerned nor surprised. The photographer was hostile, fixated on the site, and strangely uninterested in archaeology. Two weeks ago, Gideon turned up on his doorstep trying to show him something. Ashby shut him out. The next night, someone had been creeping around the house, trying the doors and windows.
Ashby had never seen the vase, but the description unsettled him. He was always going to retire after the expedition, he told them. He also had a spare copy of Hargreave’s Fragments of the Thorn Cults and was happy to lend it.
GM Notes
And off we go with another game. We played The Haunting as a two-shot over Halloween and folks were so excited about playing an investigation game that we switched over. It didn't hurt that Out There was feeling like a chore to run: lots of work to wrangle and difficult for the players to make headway in pursuing their own affairs.
I went a little overboard prepping for this scenario. I set myself the goal of writing a short, introductory investigation with room to expand into something larger and instead I wrote 10,000 words of location notes, handouts, and timeline. So far that prep has been paying off well in documents that the players get to interact and mess with.
Smolthulhu is a simple d100 roll under system with 20 skills and a single "trick" for each job. Sanity rolls are scrapped in favor of a stress system a la Blades in the Dark or Darkest Dungeon. You can gain stress to reroll tests, but if something spooky happens and you fail, you try to roll over your accumulated stress to see if avoid panicking. Stress is easy to gain and hard to bail off. So far all of this has worked well enough.
I did accidentally forget to give the investigators starting gear. Oops! It speaks to how much I just don't care about that for this game, and easy enough to retcon in next session.
As with any historical campaign it will be interesting to dial in what historical prejudices get depicted and which fade offscreen. We're already clearly playing at the margins of orientalism - the literal Oriental Institute is center stage. My hope is that if we keep the crosshairs on it, we'll be working through an interesting story operating on those tropes rather than simply falling into them. Or so I hope.